Indian Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine   Official publication of Indian Association of  0ccupational  Health  
 Print this page Email this page   Small font sizeDefault font sizeIncrease font size
 Users Online:1098

  IAOH | Subscription | e-Alerts | Feedback | Login 

Home About us Current Issue Archives Search Instructions
  Search
 
   Next article
   Previous article 
   Table of Contents
  
 
    Similar in PUBMED
     Search Pubmed for
     Search in Google Scholar for
   Related articles
    Article in PDF (115 KB)
    Citation Manager
    Access Statistics
    Reader Comments
    Email Alert *
    Add to My List *
* Registration required (free)  


   Abstract
   Introduction
   Definitions
   Historical Backg...
   Importance of HWE
   Components of HWE
   Factors Affectin...
   Avoiding HWE
   Conclusion
   References
   Article Tables

 Article Access Statistics
    Viewed6023    
    Printed264    
    Emailed0    
    PDF Downloaded396    
    Comments [Add]    
    Cited by others 34    

Recommend this journal

 


 
REVIEW ARTICLE
Year : 2009  |  Volume : 13  |  Issue : 2  |  Page : 77-79
 

Healthy worker effect phenomenon


Cairn Energy India Pvt. Ltd, 4th Floor, Vipul Plaza, Suncity, Sector 54, Gurgaon-122 002, Haryana, India

Date of Web Publication20-Aug-2009

Correspondence Address:
Divyang Shah
Cairn Energy India Pvt. Ltd, 4th Floor, Vipul Plaza, Suncity, Sector 54, Gurgaon-122 002, Haryana
India
Login to access the Email id

Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None


DOI: 10.4103/0019-5278.55123

Rights and Permissions

 

  Abstract 

The Healthy Worker Effect (HWE) phenomenon has been under debate since some years. Some epidemiologists regard HWE as an ordinary method problem while others consider it a field of science by itself. This article gives definitions of HWE explained with historical background; discusses factors affecting it and suggests methods to minimize problems associated with it.


Keywords: Healthy Worker Effect, occupational epidemiology, selection bias


How to cite this article:
Shah D. Healthy worker effect phenomenon. Indian J Occup Environ Med 2009;13:77-9

How to cite this URL:
Shah D. Healthy worker effect phenomenon. Indian J Occup Environ Med [serial online] 2009 [cited 2019 Apr 24];13:77-9. Available from: http://www.ijoem.com/text.asp?2009/13/2/77/55123



  Introduction Top


The Healthy Worker Effect (HWE) phenomenon has been under debate since a few years. Some epidemiologists consider HWE an ordinary method problem while others consider it a field of Science by itself. In this article I shall explain various definitions of HWE with their historical background, necessary to understand the phenomena. I will also discuss factors affecting the phenomena and ways to deal with them.


  Definitions Top

"HWE is a phenomenon initially observed in studies of occupational diseases: Workers usually exhibit lower overall death rates than the general population because the severely ill and chronically disabled are ordinarily excluded from employment" - Last, 1995. [1]

Another definition by McMichael (1976) [2] who first gave it the name is: "HWE refers to the consistent tendency of the actively employed to have a more favorable mortality experience than the population at large."

However, other occupational epidemiologists describe HWE as the reduction of mortality or morbidity of occupational cohorts when compared with the general population.

Let's try to understand it by an example.

Doll and coworkers [3] studed on gas workers exposed to carbonized coal. They measured standardized mortality rate (SMR i.e. mortality rates after eliminating possible effect of age differences in workers and general population) for groups of gas workers with different kinds of exposure. Following were the observations.

Mortality (SMR-, all causes) of gas workers compared with national experience

Heavy Exposure 105

Intermediate 90

No Exposure 84

(Doll et al. 1965).

SMR is less than 100 in unexposed workers.


  Historical Background Top


This phenomenon was first observed in 1885 when William Ogle [4] found mortality rate dependent on difficulty of occupation; some occupations repel and some others attract workers. In other words, the more vigorous occupations had a relatively lower mortality rate when compared with the death rate in occupations of an easier character or among the unemployed. Almost 100 years later, in 1974, McMichael coined the term HWE to describe this phenomena. [5] A year later, Goldsmith (1975) [6] pointed out that most industrially employed cohorts should be expected to have better life expectancy than unemployed persons. SMR close to unity (100) is used as an indication of absence or a low degree of HWE.


  Importance of HWE Top


Any occupational study looking for workers' health could potentially face this problem. It is a type of bias. The question is - Is it a serious bias? Most studies indicate that HWE will reduce the association between exposure and outcome by an average of 20-30%. Looking into the previous example of British gas workers:

SMR in non exposed worker is less than 100. So this reduction in SMR could be leading us to conclude that the condition among workers is good and no harmful effect was seen. This is not true. It may partially or completely mask excess mortality or morbidity caused by harmful exposure.

Trying to understand HWE was not easy considering the ongoing debate on its nature. Some scientists consider HWE a source of selection bias; others consider it confounding. A third group considers it a mix of both while some others look at it as a comparison problem.

Selection Bias
"Error due to systematic differences in characteristics between those selected for study and those not." The selection bias occurred from the initial choosing of workers (mainly healthy workers) and factors that influence the continuity of work such as leaving the work because of sickness. To put it in simple words, HWE refers to the initial hiring into workforce and subsequent factors which influence continuing employment.

Confounding

"A situation in which a measure of the effect of an exposure on risk is distorted because of the association of exposure with other factor(s) that influence the outcome under study".

The confounding factor is the (unmeasured) health status of the group of employees.

Going back to our example, GHS is associated with exposure. (Employment in industry and associated with outcome death).

A third school of thought considers HWE a confounder and selection bias since it is very difficult to differentiate between them. The last opinion was a comparison problem. According to Olli Miettinen; [7] the best reference for a population under study (as an example A) in a specific time is with the same population at the same time without the exposure - which is impossible.[Additional file 1], [Additional file 2]


  Components of HWE Top


Healthy Hire Effect

Employers have the right to reject certain persons for employment because of physical disabilities, or poor general health. An employer will exclude those obviously at high risk. Person selection may also be influenced by habits and physical conditions such as weight, smoking, or alcoholism. This effect will vary according to the labor situation, i.e. during period of labor shortages less fit workers could be included in the labor force whereas during periods of labor surplus employers can be choosy.

Healthy Worker Survivor Effect

Workers who do not have strong motivation to work because of health problems do not present themselves for employment (self-selection). They generally change jobs frequently or retire early. They change their job for different reasons including health. The effect is reduced after 15 years of entry to the industry.

Time-since-hire

The length of time the population has been followed. HWE is a characteristic of actively employed workers. Incomplete follow-up of the out-migrating section of the cohort could result in failure to track every individual to determine his vital status. Reduction in health status could occur without any relation to exposure.

Monson (1986) [8] divided the follow-up into two phases; a dynamic phase and a stable plateau. The dynamic phase is characterized by increased relative risk (RR) with years of follow-up. The RR becomes constant after some years of follow-up (plateau).

Beneficial Effect of Work

Improved access to healthcare, routine disease screening and physical exercise is the beneficial effect of work. While there is a wide agreement on the first three factors, there is debate on the extent of the beneficial effect. Doll [3] considered low mortality a result of true benefit of work on health.


  Factors Affecting HWE Top


HWE is not constant. It varies depending on choice of comparison population. The factors affecting HWE also vary between studies.

Time Related Factors

Age at Hire


Workers with high age will be highly influenced by selective processes as the proportion of persons attaining the required level is likely to be smaller in the old age group.

Example

RR for all causes of mortality [Table 1]

Age at risk


The age at any point in follow-up that shows the outcome (death). Increasing age at risk will increase the period of follow-up and thus reduce the HWE.

Example

RR for all causes of mortality by age at risk [Table 2]

Duration of Employment

Increasing the duration of employment will increase the effect since many sick people will leave or shift to safer work.

Socioeconomic Status

HWE is stronger in more qualified jobs. Professional workers demonstrate a stronger overall HWE. based on job classification; high socioeconomic status of work (white collar) has high healthy worker effects since it requires higher qualifications.

Gender

Usually the effect is stronger for females than males.


  Avoiding HWE Top


Many efforts have been made to minimize HWE. The most straightforward way is to avoid using general population as a reference group. Use active workers from another industry who do not have the same exposure. Another way to minimize HWE is to compare rates of health outcomes of interest between individuals with high exposure and those with low or no exposures. This is useful when the external reference group is not ideal. However, it is not likely that all occupational hazards pose gradient effects on human health (many industries show uniform exposure). One can also reduce HWE by starting the study after a latency of time e.g. one year, five years etc. where the HWE is high during this period. Another way to minimize HWE is to include the experience of every person who ever worked in a particular factory or industry


  Conclusion Top


HWE is caused by an inadequate reference group (i.e. comparison problem). If we find an ideal reference group then HWE will not exist. It is a complex, problem creating bias comprising of several factors and may be modified by a number of factors. It is not possible to make generalizations in a particular case of HWE.[10]

 
  References Top

1.Last J. A Dictionary of Epidemiology. 3 rd ed. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1995.  Back to cited text no. 1    
2.McMichael AJ. Standardized mortality ratios and the "healthy worker effect": Scratching beneath the surface. J Occup Med 1976;18:165-8.   Back to cited text no. 2    
3.Doll R, Fish REW, Gammon EJ, Gunn W, Hughes GO, Tyrer FH, Wilson W. Mortality of gas workers with special reference to cancers of the lung and bladder, chronic bronchitis, and pneumoconiosis. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 1965;22:1-12.  Back to cited text no. 3    
4.Ogle W. Letter to the Registrar-General on the mortality in the registration districts of England and Wales during the ten years 1871-80. Supplement to the 45 th Annual Report of the Registrar General of Births, Deaths, and Marriages, in England: 1985.   Back to cited text no. 4    
5.McMichael AJ, Spirtas R, Kupper LL. An epidemiologic study of mortality within a cohort of rubber workers, 1964-72. J Occup Med 1974;16:458-64.  Back to cited text no. 5    
6.Goldsmith JR. What do we Expect from an Occupational Cohort. J Occup Med 1975;17:126-31.  Back to cited text no. 6    
7.Miettinen OS. Commentary: Epidemiologic methods: beyond clinical medicine, beyond epidemiology. Eur J Epidemiol 2004;19:737-9.  Back to cited text no. 7    
8.Monson RR. Observations on the healthy worker effect. J Occup Med 1986;28:425-33.  Back to cited text no. 8    
9.Fox AJ, Collier PF. Low mortality rates in industrial cohort studies due to selection for work and survival in the industry. Br J Prev Soc Med 1976;30:225-30.  Back to cited text no. 9    
10.Delzell E, Monson RR. Mortality among rubber workers. III. Cause-specific mortality, 1940-1978. J Occup Med 1981;23:677-84.  Back to cited text no. 10    



 
 
    Tables

  [Table 1], [Table 2]


This article has been cited by
1 Reliability and Validity of the Work Role Functioning Questionnaire (Spanish Version)
Jose M. Ramada,Consol Serra,Benjamin C. Amick,Femke I. Abma,Juan R. Castaño,Gemma Pidemunt,Ute Bültmann,George L. Delclos
Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation. 2014;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
2 The Association between Long Working Hours and Self-Rated Health
Jun-Taek Song,Goeun Lee,Jongho Kwon,Jung-Woo Park,Hyunrim Choi,Sinye Lim
Annals of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2014; 26(1): 2
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
3 Recovery and well-being among Helicopter Emergency Medical Service (HEMS) pilots
Mirjam Radstaak,Sabine A.E. Geurts,Debby G.J. Beckers,Jos F. Brosschot,Michiel A.J. Kompier
Applied Ergonomics. 2014;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
4 Work-related stress in midlife is associated with higher number of mobility limitation in older age—results from the FLAME study
Jenni Kulmala,Timo Hinrichs,Timo Törmäkangas,Mikaela B. von Bonsdorff,Monika E. von Bonsdorff,Clas-Håkan Nygård,Matti Klockars,Jorma Seitsamo,Juhani Ilmarinen,Taina Rantanen
AGE. 2014; 36(6)
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
5 If it is published in the peer-reviewed literature, it must be true?
Louis K. Wagner
Pediatric Radiology. 2014; 44(S3): 468
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
6 Inverse Effects of Midlife Occupational and Leisure Time Physical Activity on Mobility Limitation in Old Age-A 28-Year Prospective Follow-Up Study
Timo Hinrichs,Mikaela B. von Bonsdorff,Timo Törmäkangas,Monika E. von Bonsdorff,Jenni Kulmala,Jorma Seitsamo,Clas-Håkan Nygård,Juhani Ilmarinen,Taina Rantanen
Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. 2014; : n/a
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
7 Impacto de las nuevas guías estadounidense y británica en el manejo y el tratamiento de las dislipemias en una población laboral española
Carlos Brotons,Eva Calvo-Bonacho,Irene Moral,María Teresa García-Margallo,María Victoria Cortés-Arcas,Mireia Puig,Gastón Vázquez-Pirillo,Luis Miguel Ruilope
Revista Española de Cardiología. 2014;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
8 Impact of the New American and British Guidelines on the Management and Treatment of Dyslipidemia in a Spanish Working Population
Carlos Brotons,Eva Calvo-Bonacho,Irene Moral,María Teresa García-Margallo,María Victoria Cortés-Arcas,Mireia Puig,Gastón Vázquez-Pirillo,Luis Miguel Ruilope
Revista Española de Cardiología (English Edition). 2014;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
9 The Role of Midlife Occupational Complexity and Leisure Activity in Late-Life Cognition
R. Andel,M. Silverstein,I. Kareholt
The Journals of Gerontology Series B: Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences. 2014;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
10 Quality of life and neck pain in nurses
Lucy E. Joslin,Christopher R. Davis,Patricia Dolan,Emma M. Clark
International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health. 2014; 27(2): 236
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
11 The economic burden of disease by industry: Differences in quality-adjusted life years and associated costs
Davina V. Tolbert,Kathryn E. McCollister,William G. LeBlanc,David J. Lee,Lora E. Fleming,Peter Muennig
American Journal of Industrial Medicine. 2014; 57(7): 757
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
12 Progress towards Healthy Ageing in Europe: to promote active healthy lifestyles in 45-68 year olds through workplace, rather than traditional health-related settings
Elspeth Anne Gibson
Working with Older People. 2014; 18(2): 51
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
13 Ergonomics and Bronchoscopy
Christopher R. Gilbert,Jason A. Akulian,David Feller-Kopman,Lonny Yarmus
Journal of Bronchology & Interventional Pulmonology. 2013; 20(2): 113
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
14 Cause and effect in studies on unemployment, mental health and suicide: a meta-analytic and conceptual review
A. Milner,A. Page,A. D. LaMontagne
Psychological Medicine. 2013; : 1
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
15 Chronic health conditions and work ability in the ageing workforce: the impact of work conditions, psychosocial factors and perceived health
Wendy Koolhaas,Jac J. L. Klink,Michiel R. Boer,Johan W. Groothoff,Sandra Brouwer
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health. 2013;
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
16 In-Depth Study of the Workers’ Perspectives to Enhance Sustainable Working Life: Comparison Between Workers With and Without a Chronic Health Condition
Wendy Koolhaas,Jac J. L. Klink,Johanna P. M. Vervoort,Michiel R. Boer,Sandra Brouwer,Johan W. Groothoff
Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation. 2013; 23(2): 170
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
17 Social rank and inhalant drug use: The case of lança perfume use in São Paulo, Brazil
Zila M. Sanchez,Ana R. Noto,James C. Anthony
Drug and Alcohol Dependence. 2013; 131(1-2): 92
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
18 Social rank and inhalant drug use: The case of lança perfume use in São Paulo, Brazil
Sanchez, Z.M. and Noto, A.R. and Anthony, J.C.
Drug and Alcohol Dependence. 2013; 131(1-3): 92-99
[Pubmed]
19 In-depth study of the workersæ perspectives to enhance sustainable working life: Comparison between workers with and without a chronic health condition
Koolhaas, W. and Van Der Klink, J.J.L. and Vervoort, J.P.M. and De Boer, M.R. and Brouwer, S. and Groothoff, J.W.
Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation. 2013; 23(2): 170-179
[Pubmed]
20 Ergonomics and bronchoscopy: A survey of the american association of bronchology and interventional pulmonology
Gilbert, C.R. and Akulian, J.A. and Feller-Kopman, D. and Yarmus, L.
Journal of Bronchology and Interventional Pulmonology. 2013; 20(2): 113-120
[Pubmed]
21 Assessment of framingham cardiovascular disease risk among militaries in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Al-Dahi, S. and Al-Khashan, H. and Al Madeer, M.A.M. and Al-Saif, K. and Al-Amri, M.D.S. and Al-Ghamdi, O. and Al-Helali, N. and Selim, M. and Mishriky, A.M.
Military Medicine. 2013; 178(3): 299-305
[Pubmed]
22 Investigating individual- and area-level socioeconomic gradients of pulse pressure among normotensive and hypertensive participants
Matricciani, L.A. and Paquet, C. and Howard, N.J. and Adams, R. and Coffee, N.T. and Taylor, A.W. and Daniel, M.
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2013; 10(2): 571-589
[Pubmed]
23 Employment contracts and health selection: Unhealthy employees out and healthy employees in?
Wagenaar, A.F. and Kompier, M.A.J. and Houtman, I.L.D. and Van Den Bossche, S.N.J. and Taris, T.W.
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2012; 54(10): 1192-1200
[Pubmed]
24 Impact of employment contract changes on workersæ quality of working life, job insecurity, health and work-related attitudes
Wagenaar, A.F. and Kompier, M.A.J. and Houtman, I.L.D. and van den Bossche, S.N.J. and Taris, T.W.
Journal of Occupational Health. 2012; 54(6): 441-451
[Pubmed]
25 Effect of the type of population on estimates of mean body mass index and prevalence of overweight and obesity: A systematic review of studies of Portuguese adults
Carreira, H., Pereira, M., Azevedo, A., Lunet, N.
Annals of Human Biology. 2012; 39(3): 223-238
[Pubmed]
26 Musculoskeletal symptoms and work ability among agricultural machinery operators
Milani, D., Monteiro, M.S.
Work. 2012; 41(sup 1): 5721-5724
[Pubmed]
27 Employment Contracts and Health Selection
Alfred F. Wagenaar,Michiel A. J. Kompier,Irene L. D. Houtman,Seth N. J. van den Bossche,Toon W. Taris
Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2012; 54(10): 1192
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
28 Impact of Employment Contract Changes on Workers^|^apos; Quality of Working Life, Job Insecurity, Health and Work-related Attitudes
Alfred F. Wagenaar,Michiel A.J. Kompier,Irene L.D. Houtman,Seth N. J. van den Bossche,Toon W. Taris
Journal of Occupational Health. 2012; 54(6): 441
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
29 Effect of the type of population on estimates of mean body mass index and prevalence of overweight and obesity: A systematic review of studies of Portuguese adults
Helena Carreira,Marta Pereira,Ana Azevedo,Nuno Lunet
Annals of Human Biology. 2012; 39(3): 223
[Pubmed] | [DOI]
30 Relationship of Cardiovascular Disease to Stress and Vital Exhaustion in an Urban, Midwestern Police Department
Sandra L. Ramey, Yelena Perkhounkova, Nancy R. Downing, Kennith R. Culp
AAOHN Journal. 2011; 59(5): 221
[VIEW] | [DOI]
31 Musculoskeletal Disorders and Ergonomics in Dermatologic Surgery: A Survey of Mohs Surgeons in 2010
Christine A. Liang, Vicki J. Levine, Stephen W. Dusza, Elizabeth K. Hale, Kishwer S. Nehal
Dermatologic Surgery. 2011; : n/a
[VIEW] | [DOI]
32 Towards a sustainable healthy working life: associations between chronological age, functional age and work outcomes
W. Koolhaas, J. J. L. van der Klink, J. W. Groothoff, S. Brouwer
The European Journal of Public Health. 2011;
[VIEW] | [DOI]
33 Prevalence and consequences of musculoskeletal symptoms in symphony orchestra musicians vary by gender: a cross-sectional study
Helene M Paarup, Jesper Baelum, Jonas W Holm, Claus Manniche, Niels Wedderkopp
BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders. 2011; 12(1): 223
[VIEW] | [DOI]
34 Chronic non-communicable disease risk factor survey 2010 among University of the West Indies Staff at Cave Hill, Barbados
Morris, E. and Unwin, N. and Ali, E. and Brathwaite-Graham, L. and Samuels, T.A.
West Indian Medical Journal. 2011; 60(4): 452-458
[Pubmed]



 

Top
Print this article  Email this article
Previous article Next article