|Year : 2021 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 84-90
Health of farming communities prior to modification of the occupational environment through a watershed development project in Kolar, India
Adithya Pradyumna1, Andrea Farnham2, Jürg Utzinger2, Mirko S Winkler2
1 Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, P.O. Box, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland; University of Basel, P.O. Box, CH-4003 Basel, Switzerland; Azim Premji University, PES Campus, Hosur Road, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
2 Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, P.O. Box, CH-4002 Basel; University of Basel, P.O. Box, CH-4003 Basel, Switzerland
|Date of Submission||15-Jul-2020|
|Date of Decision||08-Sep-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||01-Oct-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||9-Jul-2021|
Dr. Adithya Pradyumna
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, P.O. Box, CH-4002 Basel
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Watershed development (WSD) projects, aimed primarily at enhancing soil and water conservation and supporting livelihoods in semi-arid areas, have the potential to impact health by modifying the occupational and household environments in agrarian communities. To identify and address potential health concerns arising from a planned WSD project in Kolar district, India, a health impact assessment (HIA) was conducted. This necessitated understanding the health status and concerns in the project villages. Objective: To characterize the health of farmers and their household members in close proximity of the planned WSD project. Methods: We carried out a cross-sectional survey between April and July 2019. The study comprised: (i) a household survey covering the four project villages and two comparison villages (e.g. socio-demographic characteristics, occurrence of vector-borne diseases (VBDs), access to safe water, sanitation and hygiene, and utilization of healthcare); and (ii) an anthropometric survey for children under the age of 5 years in the four project villages and four comparison villages. Results: Respondents (n = 333) reported household-level occurrences of VBDs (chikungunya, 3.3%; and dengue, 1.5%), consuming unsafe water (54.5%) and frequent pesticide application in fields (26.7%). The prevalence of child underweight was 23.8%. Conclusions: VBDs, poor water quality and child undernutrition were found to be important local health concerns, amenable for preventive and promotive measures through the planned WSD project. Occupational environments in agricultural settings affect the workers and their households, and comprehensive projects such as WSD can seize the opportunity for improving health of farming and other rural households.
Keywords: Agriculture, health impact assessment, India, nutrition, vector-borne disease, watershed development
|How to cite this article:|
Pradyumna A, Farnham A, Utzinger J, Winkler MS. Health of farming communities prior to modification of the occupational environment through a watershed development project in Kolar, India. Indian J Occup Environ Med 2021;25:84-90
|How to cite this URL:|
Pradyumna A, Farnham A, Utzinger J, Winkler MS. Health of farming communities prior to modification of the occupational environment through a watershed development project in Kolar, India. Indian J Occup Environ Med [serial online] 2021 [cited 2021 Jul 27];25:84-90. Available from: https://www.ijoem.com/text.asp?2021/25/2/84/321069
| Introduction|| |
Almost 55% of the total workforce and their households depend on agriculture for livelihood in India. Agriculture is also a critical determinant of nutrition for this population. Occupational health of farmers has received some attention in the National Health Policy 2017 with agricultural injuries indicated as a priority concern. Most farmers depend on rainfall for cultivation, contributing to uncertainty and distress. Farmer suicides are the tip of the iceberg of the prevalent distress in the community. Soil erosion and water insecurity have further affected agricultural productivity. These, and other factors such as vulnerability to climate change, have created a precarious occupational environment for farmers and wage labourers in semi-arid rural India.
In response to these challenges, watershed development (WSD) projects have been conducted with the support of governmental and development agencies towards soil and water conservation, and sustainable livelihoods., Interventions include structures such as check-dams, tree planting, support for livestock rearing and creating local management institutions. It was envisioned that WSD projects would integrate schemes from across sectors, including nutrition-related schemes. Common guidelines for WSD projects were revised in 2008.
WSD projects have reportedly impacted positively on the health of local communities through improved sanitation and water access, enhanced dietary diversity and increased livelihood opportunities, leading to reduction in diarrhoeal disease, better nutrition and overall wellbeing.,,, However, modification of the occupational environment has led to some potential negative impacts, through changed vector ecology (e.g. increased surface water bodies), pesticide use (e.g. increase in commercial cropping) and accidents (e.g. drowning in farm ponds).
A WSD project was proposed by a non-governmental organization (NGO), MYRADA Kolar Project, for four villages in Kolar district, India in 2019. While a baseline socioeconomic study is usually conducted prior to implementing WSD projects, the idea for conducting a health impact assessment (HIA) of this proposed WSD project arose through discussion between the first author (A.P.) and the NGO to (i) deepen the understanding of local health concerns; (ii) identify potential project-related health concerns; and (iii) recommend approaches to mitigate potential risks and maximize health promotion through the planned WSD project. The literature review during the HIA revealed vector-borne diseases (VBD),, undernutrition and fluorosis, as district-level concerns. However, due to inadequate village-level health data for conducting the HIA, primary data collection was carried out to estimate these key indicators prior to the WSD project. In this paper, we present the status of selected health indicators in the local population, as identified through primary data collection within the frame of the HIA prior to the planned WSD project.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The WSD project site is located approximately 65 km east of Bengaluru city, and 30 km south of Kolar town (geographic coordinates: 12°53'-12°54' N latitude; 78°3'-78°6' E longitude). The planned WSD project will cover four villages [Figure 1]. People's primary occupation is agriculture, and the main produce is finger millet. This semi-arid area is prone to climate change.
|Figure 1: Study sites – location of project and comparison villages (source of satellite imagery: Google Earth (dated 29.03.2020, mapped using the ‘ggmap’ package in R statistical software)|
Click here to view
A cross-sectional study design was used, and the modular survey approach suggested by Winkler and colleagues for HIA in tropical contexts was applied. Two modules were included: (i) household survey; and (ii) anthropometric survey. The survey sites are depicted in [Figure 1]. The household survey was conducted in the four project villages (n = 195 households) and two comparison villages (n = 138 households). Comparison villages were chosen based on geographic proximity to study villages and similarities in socioeconomic conditions. In terms of sample size, all households were invited to participate, enabling a complete census of the included project and comparison villages. The anthropometric survey was conducted with children under the age of 5 years in the four project villages (n = 83 children) and four comparison villages (n = 77 children). All eligible children in these villages were included for the survey.
The survey was conducted between April and July 2019. Women of age 15 years or more were requested to participate on behalf of their households. After obtaining written informed consent, the survey was administered on an electronic tablet using the Open Data Kit (ODK) platform by a member of the trained survey team. The structured questionnaire contained questions on socioeconomic status, agriculture, water and sanitation, disease risk factors, experience of various diseases and access to health services. Some environmental observations were also made at each household (i.e. toilet condition, soap availability and open drains). The topics were based on needs identified in the scoping stage of the HIA. Due to human resource constraints, a few data points were not covered in the comparison villages (indicated in the respective tables).
The anthropometric assessment was done at the local governmental crèches. Few home visits were made for children who could not be brought to the crèche at the time of the survey. Weight on the nearest 0.1 kg (digital scale, Eagle EEP1007A; Pune, India) and mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) on the nearest mm (using a standard tape) were measured. In addition, sex, date of birth, date of measurement and village location of the child were noted. Data were directly entered into a template developed on ODK.
Data was analyzed using R statistical software version 3.5.1 (on RStudio version 1.1.456). As the sample included all households and all children under the age of 5 years in the project and comparison villages, confidence intervals were not calculated and statistical tests were not performed between comparison groups. The household survey data were summarized descriptively for project and comparison villages using proportions, means and medians. The anthropometric survey data were analyzed using the “anthro package” to determine z-scores for weight-for-age and MUAC-for-age based on the World Health Organization (WHO) Child Growth Standards. Moderate and severe undernutrition and undernourishment were defined as < -2 standard deviations (SD) and < -3 SD, respectively. The prevalence of underweight and undernourishment among children under the age of 5 years in the study population were estimated.
Ethical clearance was received from the Padmashree Institute of Clinical Research in Bengaluru, India (reference no. IEC-BIO-004; date of approval: 10 August 2018) and the Ethics Commission of Northwest and Central Switzerland (EKNZ; reference no. BASEC Nr Req-2018-00839, date of approval: 19 October 2018). Study details were provided to the participants and guardians, following which written informed consent was taken in the local language prior to administering the questionnaire and conducting the anthropometric assessment. An information sheet in the local language was given to participants. Data were stored in an anonymized manner on a server of the host institute.
| Results|| |
A total of 195 households from four project villages and 138 households from two comparison villages were included in the household survey. The anthropometric survey included 83 children from project villages and 77 from comparison villages. Socio-demographic characteristics of the complete study population are summarized in [Table 1]. Most of the respondents were illiterate (57.1%) and a sizeable proportion were of Scheduled Tribes (35.7%).
|Table 1: Socio-demographic characteristics of participants in the household and anthropometric surveys conducted between April and July 2019 in the study villages, Kolar district, India|
Click here to view
The situation of VBD and related determinants and strategies have been summarized in [Table 2]. One quarter of the respondents reported that their households had ever experienced a VBD. During the year prior to the survey, some respondents claimed occurrences of malaria (10.5%), chikungunya (3.3%) and dengue (1.5%) in their households. Mosquitoes were perceived as a regular nuisance by one in five respondents. The most common approach to cope with mosquito menace was using repellent vaporizers (73.9%). Almost one in two households also reported using bed nets. Over 25% of households usually visited private practitioners for managing fever. Potential vector-breeding sites, such as domestic waste (36.4%) and stagnant water in open drains (16.9%) outside the household were observed in several situations.
|Table 2: Vector-borne diseases (VBD) occurrence, risk perception and strategies in selected villages of Kolar district, India from a survey conducted between April and July 2019|
Click here to view
Drinking water quality, sanitation and hygiene
The status of water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH), and related health characteristics are summarized in [Table 3]. Groundwater was the main source of drinking water for nine in ten households. Drinking water from a village-level water purifier was only utilized by 42.1% of the households. The quality of unfiltered groundwater was perceived as satisfactory for drinking by 31.2% of the respondents.
|Table 3: Drinking water, sanitation and hygiene in selected villages of Kolar district, India from a survey conducted between April and July 2019|
Click here to view
Members with teeth discolouration was reported in 12.3% households. Health impacts of chronic fluoride exposure were not known to 33% of the respondents. While most households in project villages had their own toilets (92.8%), soap was only observed at hand-wash facilities in 48.7% of the households.
Almost seven in ten households still occasionally used firewood or kerosene stoves for cooking, often alongside natural gas. Monthly pesticide spraying for agriculture was reported by 23.4% households, with a small proportion (3.3%) applying pesticides weekly.
Nutritional status and underlying determinants
The prevalence of underweight (based on weight-for-age) and undernourishment (based on MUAC-for-age) among children under 5 years of age across eight study villages were 23.8% and 11.3%, respectively [Table 4]. Over 64% households with eligible children regularly sent them to the governmental crèche, but some households did not, for reasons that the child was too young (15.6%) or because the crèche was located in a neighbouring village (15.6%).
|Table 4: Prevalence of anthropometric failure among children under 5 years of age, and crèche utilization in selected villages of Kolar district, India from a survey conducted between April and July 2019|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Our cross-sectional survey before the planned implementation of a WSD project in Kolar district, India revealed similar socio-demographic, VBD, WASH conditions and nutritional conditions in the designated project and comparision villages. Few indicators, such as prevalence of severe undernutrition, were slightly higher in project villages, although likely not beyond what can be attributed to random variation. This similarity between project and comparison villages before project initiation is ideal for longitudinal monitoring and evaluation of project impacts. The availability of baseline health data from comparison villages will enable a trend analysis (increasing, decreasing or stagnant) or the application of the difference-in-differences approach for indicators that are dissimilar at baseline, after project completion.
Influence of occupational environment on local health
Structures such as farm ponds, wells and troughs, created to sustain rainfed farming and livestock have been demonstrated to foster mosquito breeding in Kolar district, and hence, are of concern for the planned WSD project. Malaria has largely been eliminated from these sub-districts in the past two decades, but dengue and chikungunya outbreaks continue to occur. While personal protective measures such as mosquito coils were mainly used here, similar to elsewhere in India, the opportunity for source reduction in the occupational environment exists. Just over a quarter of households in the project villages reported using private healthcare services for managing fever, which is considerably lower than the rural average (63.2%) reported for all ailments in India. This observation may indicate the presence of a functional governmental healthcare service.
A sizable proportion of households reported at least monthly application of pesticides (23.4%), probably for vegetable cultivation commonly done in the area., WSD projects increased cultivation of commercial crops such as vegetables, due to enhanced irrigation capacity and land quality. However, use of personal protective equipment was reported to be low from elsewhere in India. This indicated an opportunity for awareness about safe pesticide application.
Occupational-household environment continuum influencing health impacts
Groundwater is the source for irrigation and domestic use, and reportedly contained high levels of fluoride. Access to purified water was found to be limited (54.5%), and evidence of dental fluorosis were reported from a neighbouring sub-district. The WSD project, besides increasing water for agriculture, would also improve water quality through rainwater harvesting and groundwater recharge, which would contribute to better health.
The prevalence of underweight among children below the age of 5 years in the study area (23.8%) was slightly lower than for rural Kolar in 2016 (28.5%). Over 64% households regularly sent their children to the governmental crèche, higher than the Indian rural average of 42.3% in 2016. WSD projects are known to improve food security, access to vegetables, fruits and animal source foods,, and also access to sanitation, and so the planned WSD project can be expected to enhance local nutritional status.
A few eligible children could not be surveyed as they were unavailable despite two follow-up visits upon absence in the initial survey date. The reason provided was that they were visiting relatives in other areas. Few houses were also found to be locked during the survey and two follow-up visits. However, these numbers were small and so the potential bias on our results is negligible, even if these households were systematically different from those included in the survey. Additionally, most of the respondents were illiterate (56.9%). This may have impacted the accuracy of their responses on disease occurrence. Finally, as this was a pilot study with limited resources for a relatively small WSD project with potentially minor health implications, clinical examinations were not conducted and biological samples were not collected for testing infectious, chronic and nutritional diseases in the study population, as is typical for HIAs of large projects.
| Conclusions|| |
The results of the cross-sectional baseline survey provided insights into various local health concerns relevant to the project context, including VBDs, water quality and child nutrition. These concerns reflected the seamless continuum of the occupational and household environments in agricultural communities, especially in the context of WSD projects. The data collected set a benchmark against which the project will be evaluated in the future. The modular survey approach adopted here holds promise for impact assessments of development projects in India, as is being done in other settings internationally, towards contributing to environmental health decision-making and improving occupational and environmental health outcomes for India's large agrarian population.
We would like to thank Mr Shiva Shankar and his team at the MYRADA Kolar Project for the field support during this study.
Financial support and sponsorship
The first author was a PhD student from India sponsored by the Swiss Government Excellence Scholarships (ESKAS). This paper is part of his doctoral thesis. No other funding was obtained for this study. The Federal Commission for Scholarships for Foreign Students (Bern, Switzerland) did not have any role in the design of the study and collection, analysis, and interpretation of data and in writing the manuscript.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Government of India. Agricultural Statistics at a Glance 2018. New Delhi: Government of India; 2019.
Kadiyala S, Harris J, Headey D, Yosef S, Gillespie S. Agriculture and nutrition in India: Mapping evidence to pathways. Ann N Y Acad Sci 2014;1331:43-56.
Government of India. National Health Policy 2017. New Delhi: Government of India; 2017.
Manjunatha AV, Ramappa KB. Farmer suicides in Karnataka-report submitted to Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Department of Agriculture, Cooperation & Farmers Welfare, Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Government of India, New Delhi. Bengaluru: Institute for Social and Economic Change; 2017.
Government of India. Common Guidelines for Watershed Development Projects-2008 (revised 2011). New Delhi: Government of India; 2011.
INCCA. Climate Change and India: A 4X4 Assessment. New Delhi: Government of India; 2010.
Technical Committee on Watershed Programmes in India. From Hariyali to Neeranchal-Report of the Technical Committee on Watershed Programmes in India. New Delhi: Government of India; 2006.
Smyle J, Lobo C, Milne G, Williams, M. Watershed Development in India: An Approach Evolving through Experience. Washington, DC: The World Bank; 2014.
Meenakshi AK, Ramanathan S. Evaluation of Watershed Programmes and LEISA. Bengaluru: MYRADA; 2010.
Pandit, A. Watershed Development Inputs and Social Change. Jaipur: Rawat Publications, Watershed Organisation Trust; 2010.
Nerkar SS, Tamhankar AJ, Johansson E, Lundborg CS. Improvement in health and empowerment of families as a result of watershed management in a tribal area in India - A qualitative study. BMC Int Health Hum Rights 2013;13:42.
Nerkar SS, Pathak A, Lundborg CS, Tamhankar AJ. Can integrated watershed management contribute to improvement of public health? A cross-sectional study from hilly tribal villages in India. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2015;12:2653-69.
Nerkar SS, Tamhankar AJ, Johansson E, Lundborg CS. Impact of integrated watershed management on complex interlinked factors influencing health: Perceptions of professional stakeholders in a hilly tribal area of India. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2016;13:285.
Pradyumna A, Mishra A, Utzinger J, Winkler MS. Perceived health impacts of watershed development projects in southern India – A qualitative study. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020;17:3448.
Pradyumna A, Farnham A, Utzinger J, Winkler MS. Health impact assessment of a watershed development project in southern India: A case study. unpublished 2020.
Ghosh SK, Tiwari S, Ojha VP. A renewed way of malaria control in Karnataka, south India. Front Physiol 2012;3:194.
Balakrishnan N, Katyal R, Mittal V, Chauhan LS. Prevalence of Aedes aegypti
-the vector of dengue/chikungunya fevers in Bangalore City, Urban and Kolar districts of Karnataka state. J Commun Dis 2015;47:19-23.
IIPS. National Family Health Survey-4: District fact sheet: Kolar, Karnataka. Mumbai: International Institute for Population Sciences; 2016.
Shruthi MN, Santhuram A, Arun H, Kishore Kumar B. A comparative study of skeletal fluorosis among adults in two study areas of Bangarpet taluk, Kolar. Indian J Public Health 2016;60:203-9.
] [Full text]
Shruthi MN, Anil NS. A comparative study of dental fluorosis and non-skeletal manifestations of fluorosis in areas with different water fluoride concentrations in rural Kolar. J Family Med Prim Care 2018;7:1222-8.
] [Full text]
Directorate of Census Operations Karnataka. Census of India 2011-Karnataka District Census Handbook - Kolar - Village and Town Directory. New Delhi: Government of India; 2014.
IISc. Transitioning towards climate resilient development in Karnataka-Summary for policy makers. Bengaluru: Indian Institute of Science; 2014.
Winkler MS, Divall MJ, Krieger GR, Schmidlin S, Magassouba ML, Knoblauch AM, et al
. Assessing health impacts in complex eco-epidemiological settings in the humid tropics: Modular baseline health surveys. Environ Impact Assess Rev 2012;33:15-22.
Hartung C, Lerer A, Anokwa Y, Tseng C, Brunette W, Borriello G. Open Data Kit: Tools to build information services for developing regions. In Proceedings of the 4th
ACM/IEEE International Conference on Information and Communication Technologies and Development, ACM: London, United Kingdom; 2010. p. 1-12.
R Core Team R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Version 3.5.1; R Foundation for Statistical Computing: Vienna, Austria, 2018.
Schumacher D, Borghi E, Polonsky J. Computation of the WHO child growth standards. Version 0.9.1; 2019.
Dimick JB, Ryan AM. Methods for evaluating changes in health care policy: The difference-in-differences approach. JAMA 2014;312:2401-2.
Ghosh SK, Dash AP. Larvivorous fish against malaria vectors: A new outlook. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 2007;101:1063-4.
Babu BV, Mishra S, Mishra S, Swain BK. Personal-protection measures against mosquitoes: A study of practices and costs in a district, in the Indian state of Orissa, where malaria and lymphatic filariasis are co-endemic. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 2007;101:601-9.
Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation. Key indicators of social consumption in India: Health-NSS 75th
round (July 2017 – June 2018). New Delhi: Government of India; 2019.
Mohanty MK, Behera BK, Jena SK, Srikanth S, Mogane C, Samal S, et al
. Knowledge, attitude and practice of pesticide use among agricultural workers in Puducherry, South India. J Forensic Leg Med 2013;20:1028-31.
IIPS; ICF. National Family Health Survey (NFHS-4), 2015-16: India. Mumbai: International Institute for Population Sciences; 2017.
Knoblauch AM, Winkler MS, Archer C, Divall MJ, Owuor M, Yapo RM, et al
. The epidemiology of malaria and anaemia in the Bonikro mining area, central Côte d'Ivoire. Malar J 2014;13:194.
Winkler MS, Furu P, Viliani F, Cave B, Divall M, Ramesh G, et al. Current global health impact assessment practice. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020;17:2988.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]